A scary story?
Let me guess – it’s my cloudy eyes and wrinkles and my tweedy hair? Or maybe you think anything would sound scarier told in a high scratchy voice like I been stuck with for something like 20 years now? Or maybe you’ve noticed that sometimes I limp and sometimes I don’t, right? Pretty odd?
Eh, that all helps but it’s not really the point. You know that I grew up in the Green Eggs and Ham Cult. And you figure, nothing that spooky has happened to anyone else of your acquaintance, so you come to me for your scary story.
Apple anyone? No? All right, sit down on the stoop or the lawn – hey, don’t touch my lawn chairs. That’s right. Here’s my story.
First of all, we never called ourselves the Green Eggs and Ham Cult. That’s what the news people called it when they all broke in on us that Sunday morning, scared us half to death, and found us all eating a communal meal and it happened t’ be green eggs and ham. Well, that was because Silly Sadie had been in charge of the food and she was crazy about Dr. Seuss. But actually, we just called ourselves the Bethel Brethren.
And now.
I am about tell you of the most frightening thing that ever happened to anyone I know. Me? Phhhbbb. No, if it happened to me I would be too embarrassed to tell you about it. It happened to my friend….Polly. Yep. Polly.
She had a limp, too, only it was all the time and it hurt pretty bad.
And because of that, and for some other reasons I won’t go into, none of the boys wanted to look at her.
When Polly was seventeen, on a night when the moon hid herself and darkness fell over the whole valley, Polly went out the back door of her mother’s house while her mother was half-drunk and listening to old records with her friends. Polly went out the back door and walked down the path that went right into the woods. She went right through the woods in the dark, and although she could hear the Sheep that Fly by Night rustling in the tops of the trees, none of them dropped on her head and she made it safely out the other side to her friend Belda’s house. Belda’s mother was giggling and tossing down cranberry wine in Polly’s house, crooning along with Bing Crosby and Polly’s mother.
“Evening Belda,” Polly said.
And Belda said, in a shaky voice, “Wisha washa wisha washa…”
And Polly said “Munga,” to show that she really was Polly, and knew the password.
Belda, leaning over the back fence of her mother’s garden, sighed loudly. ‘Whew. I heard you crashing through the woods and I thought for sure it was the Horned Hobelisk. Were you evading the Sheep that Fly By Night?”
“Classic zig-zag pattern,” Polly said. “Successful, as you see.”
“Come in,” Belda said.
They got into Belda’s mother’s cupboard and she had an open bottle of cranberry wine she hadn’t taken to Polly’s house, and they drank a spoonful each and settled down on a bench at the front of the house, in case any boys should walk by.
Pretty soon, a gaggle of three boys came up. Bill Willings had the point position at the front of the V, and he was clapping his hands in a pattern of three out of four. Bill was a natural born leader and he had curly bronze hair. When the girls called to them the boys stepped sideways in through the gate before looking at the girls, and then Bill stopped clapping and they all knew they were safe from the Meetin’ Gobbler.
Heh? Oh. Well, the Meetin’ Gobbler lurks around wherever men and women are in the same company, and he’ll gobble various parts of your body if you don’t observe the proper ceremonies.
I know quite well you don’t believe in The Meetin’ Gobbler! I’m telling the story how it happened, not how you believe it happened, so hush up or get off my lawn!
Well.
The boys said, “Who’s there, Belda?” because it was so dark they couldn’t see.
And Belda said, “Why don’t you come over and find out?”
Well, the boys came over, and Polly tried to disguise her voice but…er…she couldn’t. So pretty soon Bill said, “Oh, it’s Polly.” And then everyone was really quiet for a minute. And then Bill asked Belda to go for a walk but she wouldn’t because she didn’t want to step outside the boundary of her mother’s fence and risk the Meetin’ Gobbler getting her.
But Bill said, “Don’t worry, Belda. If the Meetin’ Gobbler comes up to us, I’ll knock him silly for ya’, just like Vannery did for Melaynee.”
Oh, that’s a good story. See, twelve year earlier, Vannery and Melaynee stepped out one evening, saying they didn’t believe in the Meetin’ Gobbler anyhow. Pure blasphemy. Well, Melaynee’s mother and father were frantic, and the whole valley heard the frightened parents hollerin and they all come running, the Rev Battsea, and the Council of Three and the families. But Vannery and Melaynee come back an hour later, all messy, and Vannery tells ‘em this story about how the Meetin’ Gobbler come up to ‘em and tousled up Melaynee’s clothes, trying to get his big ol’ gobber at her knees, you know. And Vannery come up behind and knocked the Gobbler silly before he could gobble anything, and that’s how they get away. All the kids crowded around, saying stuff like “Did you really see the Gobbler?” and “How bad was his breath?”
And Melaynee just kept nodding and her eyes were all big and she couldn’t even talk. But Vannery said, “I know one thing. I’m the man to protect Melaynee for the rest of her life, so I think I’ll take her home with me, if you don’t mind.” The council stares at him for a while, but he stares ‘em all down, and Vannery and Melaynee was the first couple to get married since the Valley was settled by us.
Well, back to the night Polly went to visit Belda. Belda had refused to step out, saying Bill was too wimpy to fight off any Gobbler. And then Polly got up her nerve and said, “I disagree. I’m sure Bill could defend…any girl.”
And then it was all quiet again, till Bill said he had to go see Katie, who incidentally was Melaynee’s younger sister by ten years. So the boys left, and Belda sulked for a while, till she saw that Polly was crying.
“Right just now this minute,” Polly said, after a while, “I’d take a walk with just about any boy in the world. I’d step out with the Love-Talker himself.”
Then Belda had a fit of hysterics, because the Love-Talker was worse than the Sheep that Fly by night, and the Horned Hobelisk, and the Meetin’ Gobbler put together.
But Polly, said, “I would, I would,” over and over again until Belda shrieked at her to go home. So Polly went out the front path, taking the short road home. She didn’t care if her mother saw her coming back, she was so upset.
Well, she never should have said that about the Love-Talker because he comes, right? When he’s called.
However low Polly was feeling, she wasn’t quite ready to give up all her hopes. The next day she was wandering around down the main road and thinking, and she got a bit further than she thought. And there was the little track leading off toward Vannery and Melaynee’s house. So Polly decides to get some knowing talk, and she takes off down that little track.
She comes up and finds Melaynee, getting a little billowy around the hip bones, and two children playing with a dog, and two older children working in the kitchen garden with her, in front of their yellow house. Melaynee stands up and looks at Polly and says, “Well, Polly, this is what you have to look forward to should you end up wed and bed.”
So Polly says “Wed and bed?”
Melaynee gives a short little laugh and says, “Gosh, you girls are ignorant as ever, aren’t you?”
“That’s why I came,” Polly said.
And Melaynee gives the same laugh and says, “Expert advice, eh? What do you want to know?”
Polly says, “About the Love-Talker, please.”
Melaynee rubs her nose and looks off at the sky for a bit, and then she heaves a wheezy grunt and sits on a stump and says, “Set. I’ll tell you what I think is good for you to know.”
So Polly sits down on another stump and then Melaynee starts in.
“The thing you got t’realize, Polly, is that anything I say about the Love-Talker is more or less true about all men. The Love-Talker is the same as all men only what other fellows do by straining and pushing and arguing, he does it by pure magic. You follow?”
Polly doesn’t understand all that but she nods. Melaynee keeps talking.
“So here’s what you got to watch out for. First, the Love-Talker will tell you the nicest things you ever heard, all about how wondrous’ beautiful you are, and adorable beyond all measure. And the magic is, Polly, you believe him. He’s the only one who can tell you you’re as radiant as a star and you stand there looking at how noble and upright and clear-thinking he is and you start to feel, well if he thinks I’m beautiful, it must be true. I really am radiant as a star.”
A desperate feeling begins in Polly’s chest.
“And here’s the thing… maybe you’re not radiant as a star to anyone else. The reason he’s the Love-Talker is just because you are radiant, to him.”
“There’s something wrong with his seeing?”
“Or something magic, like I said. He says it, you’re pretty sure it’s got to be true. Maybe he makes it true. Anyhow, he touches you like it is – like the tip of your shoulder or the joining of your wrist or just your smallest finger is the world’s most priceless treasure and it’s his greatest honor just to adore you for it. “
Polly’s chest gets tighter, and the tightness rises up till she’s afraid tears might squeeze out of her head. Melaynee goes right on.
“And then when he’s made you feel so good and safe and proper you get weak in the backbone, he invites you, all courtly-like, to make yourself comfortable and recline with him. Now you don’t have to do that, and don’t let anyone tell you there’s no help for it. It’s up to you at that point.”
“So he gets you to lie down? Like on a bed?”
“Like on a bed. And then he touches you, Polly.”
“Touches? Like, holds your hands?”
“Hands, face, neck, waist… and then everything else. Eventually, Polly, he touches everything. That’s what you’re not prepared for, that’s what you got to ask yourself, is it worth it?”
“He touches…”
“Yep. Nethers and all.”
Polly is truly confused. “Why? That’s not the pretty part.”
Melayneed hoots. “The Love-Talker has his own ideas about that, Polly. Anyhow, that’s the price. Once you meet the Love-Talker – well, being his girl is the only thing makes you beautiful from then on. And sometimes, just one encounter with the Love-Talker can make everyone around see how beautiful you are. ”
Polly thinks for a while, and she watches Melaynee scoop up a little two-year old kid and tickle him and kiss his face and mess his hair up. She puts the kid down and he runs away, giggling, and Melaynee just smiles after him and then looks up at the sky again and gets her face blown on by the wind.
So Polly says, “Melaynee – is it really so awful, though?”
“Hell on earth!” Melaynee says, and she grins right into Polly’s face. “Any other fellow, it would be, anyhow. The Love-Talker, though – that might be different. Might be.”
Polly stood and swayed a bit. “But I’m supposed to avoid the Love-Talker?”
“Supposed to,” says Melaynee, still grinning right at her. “Just remember, you got t’pay.”
“Pay?”
And Melaynee gestured around in a wide circle at the house and the children.
“And is that the awful part then?”
And Melaynee says, “Pretty awful some days.” But she keeps grinning, so Polly isn’t sure.
Polly was walking home that day when she met up with Bill and the other boys, just straying along. They came around a bend and happened right on each other, and there was no time to get in a V formation or observe ceremonies so they just stood there and stared at each other.
Polly stared at Bill and saw how there was something just a bit hateful about the way his nose met his eybrows and tapered off into his squinty eyes. And she laughed. She said, “Well you’re no Love-Talker, that’s for sure!” And she skipped off, just leaving them standing there.
Well, how could she know that would make him so mad?
That night Polly’s mother came into Polly’s room and grabbed Polly’s candle and rushed out. And Polly rushed out after her and when they got to the front porch they saw a parade of boys going by. Bill was in front and pretty much all the boys in the valley, even some eleven-year-olds, were marching along, holding candles in bottles.
“What are you boys doing?” Polly’s mother hollered.
They stopped and Bill turned toward the house and then they all did. “Going up to Heaven’s Hill t’ take a vow,” Bill said.
“Rev Battsea know about this?” Polly’s mother said.
“Naw,” Bill said. “It’s just something us boys are doing on our own. Nothing to do with church. We’re just taking a solemn oath never to marry anyone that limps.”
“Anyone that what?” Polly’s mother says, checking.
“Limps!” Bill shouts.
Well Polly’s mother sits down hard in a chair, but Polly stood there, not moving at all, and let the knowledge of this hatred fill her up. They watched the parade go by a bit, but then Polly’s mother saw her duty and dragged Polly back into the house and said, “Vicious prunes, Polly. But Bill Willing’s got nothing to say to the older boys – not Handley or Bob or Vester.”
Polly said nothing and she was staring at the ground, so her mother touched Polly’s hip. “Does it hurt?” she whispered. Polly didn’t answer so her mother pressed harder, and then Polly yelped, she couldn’t help it.
“Sorry, dear,” her mother said. She gave Polly her candle back and they went to bed. Polly had limped for four years, ever since she jumped out of a hayloft and landed wrong. Not enough hay in the spot and Polly hadn’t realized she was getting so long in the leg.
Well. About three weeks after the parade of boys, Polly strayed off a bit and found herself in this secluded little meadow. There were trees on all sides, and under the trees, around the whole border of the meadow, raspberry bushes were cascading inward. And there was this little hill, just off the center of the meadow, and a spring bubbled up from it and ran down away out under the trees through a gap in the raspberries and out of the meadow and out of the Valley.
Now Polly was really hungry. She mostly hadn’t eaten in the last three weeks, and from being a little plump she’d got so she could see her hip bones. She’d been moping on her bed most of the time, and staying where the boys couldn’t see her. Finally that morning she felt a little more wakeful, so she’d gotten up and bathed and put some nice-smelling stuff on, and wandered off to be by herself and think about the Love Talker and how he was probably the only man would ever look at her. And she found this meadow.
The raspberries looked so good she started to eat them and then she couldn’t stop. So here she was in the meadow, just eating and eating. Her lips got all red, and she was wearing her best nut-brown dress, with the sash tied very tightly to stave off hunger pains. And she had dyed her hair dark brown with some tree bark soak her mother made for her, and she was trying her a new way to arrange her hair.
And then all of a sudden, here comes a man, jumping over the little stream through the gap in the raspberries, and into the meadow, and into the Valley. Polly stared at him, and he stared at Polly. She stood very still so he wouldn’t find out about her limp. He had sloe-black eyes, and coal-black hair like a storm-cloud about his ears, and instead of lighting, tiny earings that shot light off ‘em. Even his skin was black, his face and his hands and the bottom of his legs that showed out under his half-length red pants.
Polly had only seen one other black-colored person in her whole life, and that was Witch Hetty, who lived on the other side of the Valley. And even Witch Hetty was only a sort of grayish-brownish black. So Polly figured, if Witch Hetty got so magic by being grayish-brownish-black, this really truly black-all-over man must be pure magic, right through. Which is why she wasn’t afraid of the Meetin’ Gobbler getting them. So she threw caution to the four corners, and held out her hands to the black-all-over man, who was walking toward her.
She didn’t say anything. But the black fellow’s face broke into such a beautiful smile and he held out his hands and said hello, like he knew just what she wanted to say. He was so beautiful she started to be afraid.
“Hello,” she said back, and then her face felt all heavy and warm and she found herself staring at the ground, she couldn’t help it.
“I’ve come to see Hetty,” the man said in a beautiful voice. He had a funny lilt to his voice, like he really owned it and knew just what to do with it, but he chose to do it different than other folks.
“I know,” Polly said.
“You do?” the man said. At first he was surprised, but then he laughed and said, “I suppose it’s obvious. I mean, how many African Americans can there be in this valley?”
“None that I know of,” Polly said, getting a little courage, “but we learned about Africa in our school.”
The man stared at her and shook his head, but then he smiled again and said, “I suppose you’re a favorite with the local boys, aren’t you.”
Polly shook her head no. It wasn’t exactly the same as being told you were radiant as a star, but it was a beginning, Polly felt.
They stood there and looked around the meadow for a while. Then the man said, “I tried to take a shortcut but I’m a bit lost. Can you tell me how to get to Hetty’s?”
So Polly took his hand and started to lead him down the meadow. “Or take me there,” the man laughed. “Just fine, just fine.”
So they went down the meadow and across some fields and then they stopped when they got to the road. The man looked at her and said, “Does your leg hurt?”
“Yes, because I’m walking,” Polly said.
So the man stopped and told her to walk around in a circle, and she showed him how it was with her limp.
“How long have you been like that?” he asked.
So Polly told him the whole story, even about the boys.
He nodded and nodded and looked a little angry. He said, “Are those boys blind? Can’t they see past a limp? Well, I think I can help you, Miss Polly. Here’s a nice dry spot. Why don’t you lie down next to the track here, on this patch of grass. Straight as you can, and maybe I can do a little magic for you. With any luck, the boys will look at you differently after this.”
Polly looked at him for a while, and sort of put things together in her mind while he waited. Then finally she said, “I know you have your own ideas about these things, but – don’t you think you could at least kiss me first? I’ve never been kissed.”
So the man stares at her a minute. And then he sits down right next to the road and puts his hand over his face and they just wait there for a while.
“I really think it’s the least you might do,” she said gently.
So the man gets up after a while and comes up real soft and kisses her forehead. She stopped being afraid right that minute.
“Thank you,” she said, looking straight at him, and he looked sad.
Then she lay down in the road and got her limbs all straight, and sure enough he starts in touching the lower regions of her body, saying nothing at all, and still looking a little sad, but very business-like – he knows what he’s doing. First he feels her lower back, then he presses on her hip and she yelps. Then he bends both her legs and has her try different positions. Then finally he leans over her, pushes on her hip with his stomach and something goes, crack!
Polly cried out but he just turned her right over and started feeling her back again and then he did this and that and fiddled with her and a few times he straightened out her legs again and then gave her a tiny punch in the back with his knuckles. Then he made her go crack a few more times, and then he did more with his knuckles. And a heavenly feeling of relief started to flood through Polly, relief about so many, many things and especially about the Love-Talker and about her leg, which was feeling sore but not wrong like it had for so long.
Finally the man let her get up and walk around. And it really was magic, because her limp was clean gone.
“A little sore, Polly?” the man asked.
And she said, “Yes, but it feels right again.”
“Good,” he said. “After I see Hetty I want to talk to your mother. You should be seen regularly for a good long while.”
“Seen?” she said.
And he sighed again. “I mean that I need to do this to you, adjust you, every week for a long time so that it will stick. Otherwise you’ll go back to limping.”
Magic worked that way all right, and Polly never expected anything different. She nodded.
“And don’t tell anyone about the kiss, all right Polly?”
“Course not,” she said, and then they started walking toward Hetty’s again.
Soon after that, they got to the main road. They passed Belda’s little sister first, and that was Anna. Anna said, “Who’s that, Polly?”
“The Love-Talker,” Polly said, all nonchalant. The man looked at Polly pretty wildly when he heard that, but he didn’t say anything. Anna ran ahead of them and they heard her talking to people, and when they went around the bend, there was a bunch of the boys from the parade. They stood off to the side and stared, and Polly went right through them with her head held high, not limping at all, holding the Love-Talker’s hand. It was the best moment in her life. They passed a lot of people on the way to Hetty’s, even Bill Willing.
And when she passed him Polly looked right at him again and said the same as last time, “No Love-Talker, that’s for sure!” But this time Bill was too flabbered to be mad. He just stood there with his eyes all big, watching.
When they finally got to Hetty’s house, the man ducked inside with a big sigh. “I never want to do that again,” he said to Hetty. And the two black people looked at each other, and then they laughed and the man said, “Hetty, you old fraud, how are you!”
And Witch Hetty said, “Shush, you’ve got one of my patients with you!”
“One of my patients now!” the man said, and he made Polly walk around and show how she wasn’t limping.
Hetty shook her head. “You gotta show me that trick,” she said.
“They’d kick me out of – everything,” the man said, but then they started discussing displaced limbs and subluxations and Polly suddenly fell asleep.
When she woke up it was dark and the man was saying, “You’ve had a good sleep, Polly, but I’ve got to get you home.”
“Have some soup first,” Hetty said, so Polly ate soup and buns while the man fretted and walked about looking at charms and things. And then they walked home.
When they arrived, Polly’s mother was very glad to see them.
“I’ve been hearing the strangest stories all day,” she said, and she looked a little white to be sure.
“Mama, you could have come to Hetty’s and checked us out,” Polly said.
“My grown up daughter? Nonsense,” Polly’s mother said breathlessly. “I was certain you could handle it, whatever it was.”
Polly showed her mother how she could walk right again and then her mother used the excuse to sit right down and have a very hard cry. As soon as he could get her to stop, the man told Polly’s mother that Polly needed to see a chiropractor every week for a while. “Can you afford that?” the man said, so Polly’s mother told him they didn’t live this way because of being poor.
“When Polly’s father died, we used the life insurance money to get a simpler life for ourselves,” she said.
“That’s all well and good,” the man said, “But I think things have gotten unnecessarily complicated for Polly.”
And Polly wanted to tell about the kiss so badly but she didn’t.
Her mother said softly, “I know that full well. We’ll come see you as soon as I can arrange it.” So the man nodded, and then he took Polly’s hand and bent over it and kissed it, softly again, and winked at her, and then we went out of the house. Polly saw him the next day from a distance, walking away from Hetty’s house with his overnight bag and heading for a different path out of the valley. They waved at each other, and that was it.
Bill came up to her and showed her a place on his arm. “Polly,” he said humbly, “look. I scratched out the vow. I shoulda’ never done that to you, Polly. You’re the prettiest girl in the valley.”
Polly looked at the place where a line had been scratched in his arm with the Sacred Scrivener, to represent the vow he’d made to never marry a person that limped. And then the second line, scratching it out. Polly sniffed.
“You didn’t need to do that on my account,” she said. “I don’t limp anymore anyways.”
She started to walk away, but he followed her a good ways, trying to talk to her. She didn’t say much back, but a lot of people saw them. That night one of the older boys, Vester, who was twenty, came by the house and sat on the porch with her. While he was there other fellows went by, two of them with the ridiculous cross-hatch scars, and tried to lean over the fence and talk to her. If they had scars she ignored them. If they didn’t she talked and laughed and brushed up against them with her shoulder.
That night when she went inside her mother looked at her and smiled a sad tired smile.
“That’s fine, Polly, that’s wonderful. I’m so glad for you,” she said. “And yet – I do wonder if any of those boys…”
“You mean would I be willing to pay for it?” Polly said, and her mother looked at her curiously.
“Like Melaynee,” Polly said, and her mother smiled. “They aren’t the Love-Talker, Mama, not any of them.”
It was Saturday night. The next morning they had their communal meal at church and right in the middle of Polly talking to Vester, past Bill’s wobegone face, some people in odd clothing rushed in and started setting up machines that turned out to be moving film cameras. The whole community was shocked and no one wanted to talk to the news people except Polly’s mother. But they rushed around filming the breakfast that no one was eating anymore and asking people how many wives they had. (No one had more than one, and the visitors seemed to find this quite disappointing.)
That day changed things for the Bretheren a lot, but Polly wasn’t around to see it. The people had gotten into the valley on motorcycles and sidecars, because the roads weren’t made for automobiles. So Polly’s mother paid one of them some money, and that night they came back with the sidecars empty, and Polly and her mother and their best things rode out of the valley, after Polly’s mother sold the house and furnishings to the next door neighbor.
After that Polly saw the black man every week, but he never kissed her again. And it turned out that – well, he was only a sort of practice Love-Talker, not really a Love-Talker at all.
The real Love-Talker, Polly’s own Love-Talker, showed up about three years later and Polly paid for it and never hesitated. And it wasn’t awful at all.
What’s that? You don’t think my story was very scary? That’s only because you weren’t there!